When it comes to investing, one of the tenets is that increased risk should be accompanied by an increase in return; however, this is far more true with stocks than it is with bonds. The fluctuations in the value of an asset or fund as a direct result of changes in interest rates are known as interest rate risk. Stocks carry this risk.
It was unusual for investors to earn larger profits while also taking on increased interest rate risk from 1982 to 2019. It is not always the case that the average return on bonds is what you would expect.
If you are considering making an investment in bonds, it is essential to have a solid understanding of the relationship between risk and return. Examine a few case studies to obtain a better understanding of how interest rates, yields, and risks interact with one another across the duration of bond maturities.
The connection between return and exposure to risk
To get a handle on the risk that is there in the bond market, the first step is to realize that the link between risk and yield is distinct from the relationships that exist between risk and average or total return.
There is a direct correlation between risk and yield due to the fact that investors require higher returns in exchange for assuming greater risks. When there is a significant risk associated with interest rate fluctuations, when there is greater sensitivity to the health of the bond's issuer, or when there are changes in the economic outlook, they will require a higher yield.
Bonds that are issued by less established nations or corporations typically have yields that are higher than average, whereas below-average yields are more common for securities issued by large corporations or governments that are financially secure.
Despite the fact that the bond market has been bullish and on the rise for over 30 years, you cannot always expect risk and total return to go hand in hand over all time periods. You cannot always expect risk and total return to go hand in hand.
The following Vanguard funds illustrate the highs and lows experienced between different time periods, which may influence the decisions made by investors.
Five-Year Funds Offered by Vanguard Prior to April 2013
Up until April 30, 2013, these were the average annual five-year returns of three Vanguard funds. This was right before the bond market began to decline, so these returns were quite favorable.
ETF on short-term bonds offered by Vanguard (BSV) yields 3.02 percent.
ETF (BIV) from Vanguard that invests in intermediate-term bonds: 6.59 percent
ETF on long-term bonds offered by Vanguard (BLV) yields 9.39 percent.
According to the data, the higher the returns on your investment would have been throughout this period of time, the longer the maturity of your investment would have been. Remember that this was part of a longer trend of declining bond yields, and keep this in mind. When yields go up, the relationship between the length of time until maturity and the total return will be flipped on its head.
When bond yields go up, it often results in a downward trend for prices. The inverse is also true, and these fluctuations often follow the overall market interest rate as they move up and down.
April 2013 through September 2013 for the Vanguard Five-Year Funds
The events that took place between April 30 and September 30, 2013, shed light on the links that exist between the duration of the maturity period, the rise in yield, and the overall return. Yields on long-term bonds increased, as did the yield on the 10-year Treasury note of the United States, which was used as a benchmark. They skyrocketed from 1.67 percent to 2.62 percent, which demonstrates a rapid decrease in prices.
The following table details the returns generated by the same three exchange-traded funds (ETFs) throughout the specified time period. Prices increased by larger percentage points while yields decreased as a function of their level of maturity. Take note of the swing in the long-term ETF yield that is more than 20 points.
-0.41 percent, according to the Vanguard Short-Term Bond ETF
a loss of 4.70 percent for the Vanguard Intermediate-Term Bond ETF
a loss of 10.76 percent for the Vanguard Long-Term Bond ETF
Bond funds appear to be more susceptible to market fluctuations to the extent that their maturities are extended.
Funds offered by Vanguard that have a term of five years, from 2014 to 2019
Since October 2018, yields on 10-year Treasury notes have been on a downward trend, whereas yields on five-year products offered by Vanguard have surged.
As of March 4, 2020, the following is a breakdown of the five-year returns covering the years 2014 through 2019:
ETF on short-term bonds offered by Vanguard: 2.00 percent
2.72 percent, according to the Vanguard Intermediate-Term Bond ETF
5.51 percent, according to the Vanguard Long-Term Bond ETF
The connection between bond yields and maturities is often unchanging over time. When let to mature for a longer period of time, yields increase. The direction in which interest rates move has a direct impact on the relationship between maturity and total return.
When yields are increasing, bonds with shorter maturities will generate better total returns than bonds with longer maturities. When yields fall, bonds with longer maturities will generate superior total returns than their shorter-term equivalents because of the compounding effect. When rates move down, it's good news for bond prices. The further they are discounted, the higher the prices will become.
2020 Bond Fund Returns
As of September 30, 2020, the following are the total returns numbers for the various bond maturity categories within the Vanguard exchange-traded fund (ETF) bond fund category performance figures:
Category 1-Year 3-Year 5-Year\sUltra Short-Term 2.36 percent 2.40 percent 1.88 percent
Short-Term
4.80 percent 3.42 percent 2.51 percent
Intermediate-Term
8.50 percent
6.25 percent
4.86 percent
Long-Term
12.78 percent
10.20 percent 8.75 percent
It is important to keep in mind that the prior performance data for funds and categories can change rapidly, which makes analyzing them challenging. Bond prices have fallen significantly over the past few years, which has resulted in yields reaching levels not seen in many years.
The Bottom Line If the current bull market in bonds comes to an end and interest rates keep climbing for an extended period of time, then investors won't be able to reap the same benefits from owning longer-term bonds as they did from 2008 to 2019. This is because longer-term bonds carry a higher interest rate. (According to previous statements, the Fed intends to do so.)
Do not make the assumption that an investment in a long-term bond fund will guarantee performance merely because the yield on such an investment is higher.
It is never a good idea to assume that bonds and investments will have a comparable future performance based on their historical performance. Bonds have often offered reasonable returns over the past few decades, but there is no guarantee that this will continue to be the case.
Questions That Are Typically Asked (FAQs)
When you buy a bond on the open market, what do you name the yearly rate of return that you will receive?
Bond traders who engage in business on the open secondary market are required to have an understanding of the dissimilarities between a bond's coupon rate and its yield rate. The yield rate is the real rate of return that traders will obtain for the amount that they paid for that bond. Hence it is frequently the most important factor for them to consider when making trading decisions. It is possible that this is not the rate of return that the initial bondholder will get; the term "coupon rate" refers to this rate. When there is a change in the price of the bond because of the forces of the market, there will also be a change in the yield rate. Because it is always the price of the payment in comparison to the initial price of the bond, the coupon rate does not fluctuate over the life of the bond.
How can you figure out what the rate of return is on a bond?
To get the rate of return on the bond, all that is required is to divide the annual payment by the current value of the bond on the market. The interest payment, which is sometimes referred to as the "coupon," stays the same despite the fact that market factors cause the price of the bond to fluctuate. Let's say there was a bond available for $1,000 that would pay a total of $50 over the course of the year. In this scenario, we would divide 50 by 1,000 to determine your rate of return, which would be 0.05, which is the same as 5%. If the price of the bond dropped to $800, then the interest rate would increase to 6.25 percent (50 multiplied by 800 is 0.0625).