There are minute distinctions between what constitutes an IRA transfer and what constitutes an IRA rollover. The key point to keep in mind is that for the rollover to be tax-free in both situations, the money must be deposited in the new account no longer than 60 days following the date they were withdrawn from the old one (unless it's a trustee-to-trustee transfer, which is covered in more detail below).
You should be aware of the following information regarding how these IRA rollovers and transfers operate and what you can and cannot do.
Transacting With Money While Working
You cannot typically withdraw money from a company retirement plan while you are still working for the company. You can call the plan sponsor and inquire about whether they permit what is referred to as an "in-service distribution" to find out if they do. The plan need not offer this choice.
In contrast to loans and hardship withdrawals, in-service distributions are a different kind of transaction. An "in-service distribution" occurs when a portion of the assets of your plan are transferred into a self-directed IRA account while you are still employed. It's only possible under some plans.
The regulations alter as soon as you leave your job there. At that point, rolling plan funds into an IRA account might make sense. If you want to prevent tax withholding, the best option is a direct IRA rollover, in which the check is written out to your new banking institution as the new trustee or custodian.
Although most people associate an IRA rollover with transferring money from a 401(k) plan to an IRA, you can also do a reverse rollover by transferring IRA funds back into a 401(k) plan. Using this reverse rollover option can be a way to combine all of your small IRA accounts if your employer plan provides good fund options with reasonable fees and you have small IRA accounts scattered throughout the country.
The Tax Obligations When Transferring Money From an Employer Plan to an IRA
You must have 20% of eligible rollover distributions paid directly to you withheld for federal taxes. This is delivered right to the IRS. This still applies even if you want to roll the distribution over to a traditional IRA. You can avoid this necessary tax withholding by choosing the direct rollover option, which makes the distribution check payable to your new financial institution directly.
IRA Fund Transfers from One to Another
A direct transfer of IRA funds from one financial institution to another, typically between similar accounts, is known as an IRA transfer (such as a traditional IRA at one custodian can transfer to a traditional IRA at a new custodian). The transfer is tax-free as long as you are not due any distributions.
Tax-free Use of IRA Funds If Making a Second IRA Deposit
The transaction would not be subject to taxes if you withdraw money from an IRA and immediately deposit it back into your account within 60 days. This kind of IRA transfer is limited to one per 12-month period. Transfers made directly from one institution to another through trustee-to-trustee relationships are exempt from the one-per-year restriction.
This 60-day allowance could be used to temporarily "borrow" money from your IRA. However, suppose any portion of the distribution is not paid back within the allotted 60 days, and you are under the age of 59 1/2. In that case, it will be regarded as an early IRA withdrawal and will be subject to taxes and penalties unless you are eligible for an exception.
Rollover Used to Transfer Part of Account
Fortunately, IRA rollovers don't have to be all or nothing. When you retire, you can roll over a portion of your company retirement plan to an IRA or use an IRA rollover to transfer money from one IRA to another.
Receiving and Transferring Money Into Your Own Account
If you receive a traditional IRA from your spouse, you have two options: roll the money into your account or designate it as an inherited account. Both options have advantages and disadvantages.
You cannot roll over or permit a rollover contribution to be made to a traditional IRA that you inherit from someone other than your spouse. The required minimum distribution (RMD) regulations state that you must withdraw the IRA assets within a specific time frame.
Minimum Distributions Requirements and Rollover Requirements
Amounts distributed in a particular year to be eligible for IRA rollover treatment are not subject to the required minimum distribution regulations. To fulfill the RMD requirements, you can distribute shares of investments from your IRA. The shares can then continue to be held in a brokerage account that is not for retirement. Any amount distributed from your IRA, whether it be in the form of cash or shares, will be reported on a 1099-R and will be counted as income on your tax return.
Tax Return Reporting of Rollover Transactions
Although they are not taxable transactions, IRA rollovers are reported on your tax return. Even if you execute an IRA rollover correctly, it's possible that the custodian or trustee of your plan will report it incorrectly on the 1099-R they send to you and the IRS. In my career, I have witnessed this happening a lot.
In the event that your custodian reported the transaction incorrectly, your tax advisor might report it incorrectly on your return if you hand them the paperwork without first explaining it to them. Explain any IRA rollover or transfer transactions in detail to your tax preparer, or double-check all supporting documentation if you prepare your own return to ensure you don't have to pay tax on them.
After-Tax Fund Rollover to a Roth IRA
According to recent tax rulings, after-tax funds from a qualified company plan may be rolled over to a Roth IRA. This is a fantastic choice because Roth IRA funds grow tax-free, and there are no mandatory distributions from a Roth.
IRA Transfer of Company Stock from Plan
Once you have retired or stopped working there, you might be able to use a unique tax rule to distribute shares of company stock from the plan. It is a selection of shares known as Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA). You might be able to directly transfer existing shares from some 401(k)s to IRAs. Many organizations demand that the money be transferred to your IRA as cash as opposed to shares.
To find out what options for distribution are available, speak with the financial custodian of your 401(k).
Questions and Answers (FAQs)
Do I have to convert my 401(k) to an IRA when I leave my job?
There are other options besides converting your 401(k) to an IRA. However, if your employer permits it, you should roll that money over into a new IRA, roll it into an existing IRA, or move it into another 401(k) to avoid taxes and penalties (k). If you keep 401(k) or IRA money for longer than 60 days, you'll owe taxes and a 10% penalty if you're under 59 1/2.
Are multiple IRAs permissible for me?
IRA accounts can be opened in multiples. Think about establishing both a traditional and a Roth IRA. The IRA contribution caps apply to each account you have, regardless of how much you have to contribute. The maximum IRA contribution for 2022 taxes is $6,000 for individuals under the age of 50 and $7,000 for those in that bracket.
The number of times I can roll over my IRA is up to me.
The IRS caps the number of rollovers you can make. In any 12-month period, you are only permitted to roll over one IRA, whether it be to another IRA or the same IRA. This restriction has a few exclusions.